Caitlin Clement|2/22/2024|4 min read

The Four Levels of Healthcare Interoperability (And Why They’re Important)

Foundation, regulation and challenges

doctor securely inputting PHI into a protected and interoperable EHR

In the dynamic landscape of modern healthcare, interoperability stands as a crucial pillar in achieving seamless data exchange and integration across various systems and platforms. 

Often described as the ability of different information technology systems and software applications to communicate, exchange data and use the information that has been exchanged, interoperability in healthcare is multifaceted and operates on four distinct levels: foundational, structural, semantic and organizational. Understanding and leveraging these levels is crucial for healthcare leaders aiming to optimize health outcomes for both individuals and populations.

Foundational interoperability

Building the framework

This is where most of the industry is currently at; step one. At its core, foundational interoperability addresses the basic ability of two or more systems to exchange data. It involves the technical compatibility to transmit data from one system to another without losing or corrupting information. If you’re in healthcare IT, you know this is easier said than done thanks to legacy systems and outdated policies.

In healthcare, this level ensures that systems can send and receive data in a consistent format, typically through standardized protocols such as HL7 (Health Level Seven) or FHIR (Fast Healthcare Interoperability Resources). Foundational interoperability lays the groundwork for higher levels of interoperability by enabling data exchange between systems, forming the foundation upon which more advanced functionalities are built.

Structural interoperability 

Standardizing the format

Moving beyond basic data exchange, structural interoperability focuses on the standardization of data formats and syntax. It ensures that data exchanged between systems are interpreted accurately and consistently. This level involves defining the structure and organization of data elements within a message, including data types, field lengths and allowable values. 

By adhering to predefined standards such as DICOM (Digital Imaging and Communications in Medicine) for medical imaging or CDA (Clinical Document Architecture) for clinical documents, structural interoperability enables seamless integration and interpretation of data across disparate systems. This standardization enhances data usability and reduces the need for manual intervention, streamlining workflows and improving efficiency in healthcare delivery.

Semantic interoperability

Understanding the meaning

Semantic interoperability represents the highest level of interoperability, focusing on ensuring that exchanged data is understood and interpreted accurately by both humans and machines. 

At this level, emphasis is placed on harmonizing the meaning of data elements across systems, regardless of differences in terminology or coding schemes. Achieving semantic interoperability involves the use of standardized terminologies, ontologies and coding systems to represent clinical concepts in a universally understood manner. 

Examples of these include SNOMED CT (Systematized Nomenclature of Medicine - Clinical Terms) for clinical terminology and LOINC (Logical Observation Identifiers Names and Codes) for laboratory observations. By aligning data semantics, semantic interoperability facilitates precise clinical decision-making, enhances care coordination and supports advanced analytics and research initiatives. It’s the final boss level in healthcare interoperability that the industry is still struggling to win. 

Organizational interoperability

Aligning processes and policies

While the first three levels focus on technical aspects of interoperability, organizational interoperability addresses the alignment of processes, policies and governance structures to support seamless data exchange and collaboration across healthcare entities. 

This level involves establishing agreements, protocols and workflows that govern data sharing among organizations, including healthcare providers, payers and public health agencies. Organizational interoperability requires clear leadership, effective communication and robust governance frameworks to address legal, privacy and security considerations while promoting data sharing for improved care coordination and population health management.

Four ways interoperability optimizes health outcomes

The road toward complete interoperability is going to be challenging, so it’s vital to remind ourselves why it’s so important to achieve. By enabling seamless data exchange and integration across disparate systems, interoperability supports:

  • Enhanced care coordination: Interoperable health information systems enable healthcare providers to access comprehensive patient data in real-time, facilitating coordinated care delivery across different settings and specialties. Timely access to relevant clinical information enhances care quality, reduces medical errors and improves patient safety.

  • Empowered patient engagement: Interoperability empowers patients to actively participate in their healthcare journey by providing access to their health records, enabling communication with their care team and facilitating shared decision-making. Patient-facing portals and mobile health applications leverage interoperable data exchange to promote engagement, adherence to treatment plans and self-management of chronic conditions.

  • Data-driven insights: Interoperability enables aggregation and analysis of data from diverse sources, including electronic health records (EHRs), wearables and population health databases. By consolidating disparate data into a unified view, healthcare organizations can derive actionable insights for disease surveillance, population health management and predictive analytics, supporting evidence-based decision-making and proactive interventions.

  • Streamlined administrative processes: Interoperability streamlines administrative workflows by automating data exchange between healthcare providers, payers and regulatory agencies. Electronic exchange of administrative data, such as claims and eligibility information, reduces paperwork, administrative burden and processing times, enabling more efficient revenue cycle management and resource allocation.

Challenges in achieving interoperability

While the benefits of interoperability are clear, healthcare leaders face several challenges in their journey toward achieving seamless data exchange and integration:

Fragmented systems and legacy infrastructure: The healthcare ecosystem contains a myriad of disparate systems, legacy infrastructure and proprietary solutions that hinder interoperability efforts. Overcoming interoperability barriers requires significant investments in technology modernization, data standardization and system integration initiatives. In a nutshell, becoming interoperable is not cheap and requires significant investment.

Data governance and privacy concerns: Interoperability raises complex data governance and privacy concerns related to data ownership, consent management and compliance with regulatory requirements such as HIPAA (Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act) and GDPR (General Data Protection Regulation). Healthcare leaders must navigate legal and ethical considerations while promoting data sharing and interoperability.

Interoperability standards and semantic challenges: Achieving semantic interoperability requires alignment with standardized terminologies, coding systems and clinical guidelines. However, interoperability standards continue to evolve and semantic challenges persist due to variations in terminology usage, coding practices and local adaptations. Harmonizing data semantics across diverse systems remains a significant hurdle in achieving true semantic interoperability.

Lack of incentives and alignment of stakeholder interests: Incentivizing interoperability requires alignment of stakeholder interests, including healthcare providers, payers, technology vendors and regulatory bodies. However, conflicting priorities, competitive dynamics and reimbursement models that favor data silos can impede collaboration and hinder interoperability initiatives.

Interoperability is key to your organizations success

As the healthcare industry becomes increasingly more reliant on technology and its ability to efficiently transfer data between systems, organizations that don’t prioritize interoperable solutions now will be left behind. 

A new interoperability rule will be coming from the CMS, and if you don’t think your technology and systems will be able to support interoperability in the near future, it’s time to be proactive. To help you meet these demands, the Office of the National Coordinator for Health Information Technology (known as ONC) created the interoperability road map. It provides a more detailed look into the shared commitments and predicted outcomes. 

Powering seamless virtual care solutions 

Healthcare interoperability operates on four distinct levels—foundational, structural, semantic, and organizational—and plays a critical role in optimizing health outcomes for individuals and populations. 

By enabling seamless data exchange and integration across disparate systems, interoperability enhances care coordination, empowers patient engagement, supports data-driven insights and streamlines administrative processes. As interoperability continues to evolve, concerted efforts and collaborative partnerships are essential to overcome these challenges and unlock the transformative power of interoperable health information exchange.

Speaking of collaborative partnerships, we’d like to introduce OpenLoop, a telehealth support company offering customizable care delivery solutions to organizations like yours. We take patient experience to the next level effortlessly with API driven technology, like our HIPAA-compliant EHR platform. Our technology stack offers efficient and interoperable solutions built to scale with your business. 

Interested in learning about our core offerings? Get in touch here!

Our full suite of white-labeled virtual care services include: